Wrapper: Undisclosed
Binder: Undisclosed
Filler: Undisclosed
Brand: Caldwell Cigar Co.
Factory: Tabacalera La Alianza S.A. (Dominican Republic)
Vitola: Kartel (5 x 49)
CigarNoise Price Range: $11-$14
Source: IPCPR 2016
Was this review helpful?  [ratings]

Click the above links to see other cigars that we’ve reviewed with similar characteristics

Caldwell Anastasia – Initial Thoughts

One of the new releases from Caldwell this year is the Anastasia.  Anastasia was the fourth, and youngest, daughter of Nicholas II, the “Last Tsar” of Russia. This history reflects the intention behind the naming as a follow-up to the popular Last Tsar cigar from Caldwell.

Anastasia represents a collaboration between Caldwell and Ernesto Perez -Carrillo.  Princess Anastasia is depicted on the main band of the cigar as is the year 1918, the year of her death.  A secondary band is emblazoned with her name.

A luxurious, reddish-brown wrapper surrounds my cigar.  It feels firm with just a bit of give when I apply slight pressure to it.  Outwardly, the construction appears very good.  The seams are nearly undetectable and the cap is exceptionally neat.

I gather scents of hay and some earthiness on the wrapper.  The foot really pleases, offering hay, raisin and sweet tobacco goodness.  The cold draw is easy, and features an even larger bouquet of dried apricot, bread, hay and raisin flavors.

Caldwell Anastasia – First Third

Cedar, Dried Fruit, Honey, Baked Bread, Black Pepper

The first draws after toasting the foot produce copious amounts of smoke layered with flavor.  Cedar and dried fruit begin the profile, finishing with a honey sweetness.  I am also detecting a subdued baked bread essence in the finish, joined by a hint of black pepper.  There isn’t any real heat from the pepper flavor and it is completely absent in the retro hale.

Caldwell Anastasia Review

Caldwell Anastasia

Nearing the end of the first third, our flavors remain consistent but the black pepper heat begins to pick up a touch.  It is not at all obtuse and blends well with the other enjoyable flavors.  Smoke production is quite good but is thin in substance.  Additionally, the burn thus far has been very dependable.  While the char line hasn’t been crisp, it has been completely maintenance free.

It is rumored Anastasia’s family was disappointed that she wasn’t a boy as they were hoping for an heir to the tsar.  They may have been disappointed at the time, but this cigar is representing well as a follow-up to the Last Tsar, showcasing complex flavor transitions within the first third and great smoke production.

Caldwell Anastasia – Middle Third

Cedar, Baked Bread, Nutmeg, Tea, Mild Tobacco, Honey, Cashew, Black Pepper

Although many flavors from the first third carry over into the middle portion, there are new attendees to the party.  Cedar and baked bread continue to entertain and are complimented by hints of nutmeg, tea and mild tobacco.  Cashew and black pepper round out the guest list, mingling quietly in the corner.

The retro hale experience is smooth and full of rich, aromatic cedar with a remarkable honey finish.  The strength of this cigar is becoming more noticeable as well, accompanying heavier billows of smoke for a thicker mouthfeel.

Caldwell Anastasia Review

Caldwell Anastasia – Final Third

Cedar, Black Pepper, Tobacco, Raisins, Baked Bread, Mint, Citrus

Familiar cedar leads me into the final stage of this experience, with black pepper and tobacco flavors charging forward.  The punishing power of this duo somehow still makes room for raisin, baked bread and an interesting addition of a citrus nudge.

As witness to Anastasia’s complexity, these underlying flavors continue to transition in and out of existence during the entire final third.  It’s a truly rewarding characteristic of this cigar.  The burn has remained consistent and the draw has been just perfect from the start.

Thick and smooth, the smoke quality has really changed as well.  It is satisfying both on the palate and in retro hale. Just when I thought Anastasia had shown all her colors, the retro hale becomes heavy with a strong mint quality.  Imagine dropping a couple drops of pure mint oil right on the tongue.  With the heat becoming preventative, I finally have to call the experience a wrap.

Caldwell Anastasia Review

Caldwell Anastasia Review
9.1 Reviewer
7.7 Cigar Noise Network (3 votes)
Pros

Great Flavor Complexity

Near Perfect Draw

Maintenance Free Burn

Cons

Wavy Burn At Times

Pricepoint

Summary
The depiction of Anastasia on the main band of this cigar features a young lady with delicate features but a powerful, unabashed look on her face. This picture represents this cigar perfectly. The finer qualities of the construction were perfect but under the simple details on the outside lies an experience to really challenge your tastebuds. The only real downside to Anastasia is her price - I think some will feel it a touch high for the cigar. I truly look forward to my next dance with this lady.
Value
Burn
Draw
Flavor
Enjoyment
What Other Folks Are Saying: 3 Make some Noise
Light and smooth, yet Rich
Very smooth throughout, I was impressed that this blend followed up with so much flavor on the palate and in the retrohale despite remaining at a medium for the entire cigar. Rich flavor seems to pour out, cycling through; cashew, nougat, coffee, cream, vanilla, floral, hay, wood, white pepper, and a hint of a sassafras/sarsaparilla flavor.

I loved this blend, even though i went into it with apprehension based on other reviews and friends experience. Price wise this seems steep considering it was done in collaboration with EP Carillo. But being limited it can be justified and especially for the flavor, unfortunately most will probably overlook this cigar based on price.

The middle third showed the most complexity of the blend but without the change in the last third of the increased pepper and floral notes it wouldn't have finished as strong.
March 4, 2017, 2:52 pm
Value8
Burn9.4
Draw8.9
Flavor9
Enjoyment9.2
0
1
Unmemorable
I had high hopes for the Anastasia and was really looking forward to getting all the flavors above but from my experience it was only in the final 3rd of the cigar that i experienced them. The 1st 2/3rds werent bad but were unmemorable. i also had some initial draw issues, it opened up as it went though.
December 18, 2016, 11:33 am
Value5
Burn5.9
Draw5.2
Flavor6.6
Enjoyment4.7
1
1
Spot on Review
The flavors noted in Ted's review were spot on. My experience was a little different with a couple relights, pushing my numbers a little to the left.

If Anastasia were a tv character, she reminded me of Cersei Lanister. Demanding, Commanding, and always representing strength
August 24, 2016, 3:16 am
Value8.6
Burn8
Draw9
Flavor9.2
Enjoyment8.7
0
2
Make some Noise

 

Connect

Ted

Contributor at CigarNoise.com
Happy to be part of CN!
I hit back!
Connect

Latest posts by Ted (see all)